Our Supervisor Tried To Scam The Company Using Fake Data—But His Own Team Took Him Down

We called him “Dick.” Not because of his name—because he earned it. Loud, smug, power-trippy. The kind of guy who’d ask why you took a sick day, then follow up with, “Was it really that bad?”

He made everyone miserable.

So when he got promoted to lead the data team above us, we were actually relieved. Out of our hair. But of course, Dick couldn’t leave us alone.

He used his new team to run productivity reports—on us. Started picking apart our work habits, calling people out in meetings, trying to micromanage from two departments away.

But then he slipped.

He started submitting reports that didn’t add up. Charts that looked suspiciously… favorable to him. It was subtle at first—project success rates inflated, timelines magically shortened. Management loved it.

Except one of his own data analysts—someone quiet, sharp, and very much done with his crap—flagged it. They pulled the raw numbers. Ran the actual metrics. It was obvious: he was editing reports to make himself look like a miracle worker.

HR got involved. A formal audit was launched. Dick tried to blame the analyst. Said it was a “miscommunication.”

But receipts don’t lie.

And the day they walked him out of the office, he turned to glare at us and muttered—
“This place will burn without me.”

We didn’t say anything. Just stood there as he packed up his monitor and his tacky mug that said “Boss Mode: ON.”

The silence after he left was the sweetest sound we’d heard in months.

Now, you’d think the story ends there—bad boss gets busted, office peace restored, everyone cheers. But it didn’t.

Because what we didn’t realize was just how deep Dick’s mess went.

A week later, a couple of people from Finance showed up in our wing. At first, we thought they were there to follow up on Dick’s audit. But they weren’t asking about him.

They were asking about us.

Turns out, Dick had been doing more than inflating his success numbers. He’d been rerouting performance bonuses from completed projects to his own budget line.

That money—meant to reward developers, project managers, even interns who pulled all-nighters—had somehow ended up padding his department’s “miscellaneous expenses.”

Tens of thousands of pounds, just… misallocated.

It made us sick.

Especially Oliver—he’d led a nightmare project last year that finished early and under budget, and everyone had expected a bonus. Instead, we got a canned “thanks” email and a dry slice of cake.

Oliver sat in the meeting room, jaw clenched, muttering under his breath. “I bought that cake,” he said. “With my own money.”

And here’s where things got interesting.

Because the data analyst who flagged Dick’s fake reports—her name was Priya—wasn’t done.

She’d saved everything.

Screenshots. Time-stamped spreadsheets. Even Slack messages Dick had deleted after realizing they were a little too incriminating.

She didn’t just want him fired.

She wanted justice.

So she did something bold—she looped in Legal.

Quietly, professionally, no drama. She sent over a file she’d labeled “Evidence of Systemic Misconduct by Former Department Head.” And that’s when the ball really started rolling.

Legal launched an internal investigation, and this time they weren’t just auditing reports—they were digging into five years of project data, budget usage, performance reviews, the whole works.

It turned out Dick had been playing this game for years.

He’d mastered the art of reassigning underperforming projects to other departments right before they failed, so his record stayed spotless. He’d once even blamed a failed rollout on IT—complete with a faked email thread where he’d conveniently removed the part where he approved the risky timeline.

The deeper they dug, the worse it got.

By week three of the investigation, the company announced an internal restructuring. HR sent out a memo saying that “due to ongoing compliance reviews,” certain bonuses would be reissued.

And that’s how we got our second twist.

One morning, I came into the office and saw a message in my inbox:

Subject: Retroactive Performance Adjustment
Body: Please check your account for a corrected performance bonus deposit. We appreciate your patience and integrity.

I blinked at the number. It was double what I had expected last year. For a minute, I thought it was a mistake.

Then Oliver came over holding his phone, grinning like a kid on Christmas morning. “They paid it back,” he said, his voice cracking. “They actually paid it back.”

We weren’t the only ones. One by one, people got their bonuses restored. Not just our team—but folks from Marketing, IT, Product—all the departments Dick had “borrowed” from.

The mood around the office changed overnight.

People started staying for after-work drinks again. Laughter returned to the lunchroom. It felt like we’d all been holding our breath for years, and someone finally cracked open a window.

And Priya?

She got promoted.

Senior Data Integrity Lead.

It wasn’t just a fancy title—she now had the authority to oversee compliance across all departments. Word is, she was even helping build a new internal reporting system, designed to catch discrepancies like the ones Dick had exploited.

One afternoon, I bumped into her in the break room. I offered to buy her coffee as a thank-you. She smiled and said, “Just promise me if you ever become a manager, don’t be a Dick.”

Fair enough.

But the story still wasn’t over.

Because a month later, I got a LinkedIn message from a recruiter. She said she was hiring for a mid-level project lead role at a different company. One of their senior managers had been recently let go for “serious ethical concerns,” and they were rebuilding the team.

I clicked the company link.

Guess who used to work there?

Yep—Dick.

He’d jumped ship after our audit started, hoping to land a soft exit somewhere else. Probably thought he could keep pulling the same stunts. But people talk. And karma, as it turns out, has great hearing.

I didn’t apply for the job. But I did share Priya’s name with the recruiter. “If you want someone who’ll keep your books clean,” I wrote, “she’s the one.”

The recruiter replied two days later: “We already reached out. She’s booked solid.”

Of course she was.

I think about all this sometimes when the office is quiet and the lights are low. How close we came to letting it all slide. How easy it would’ve been to look the other way.

But Priya didn’t.

She believed in accountability. Not just for her boss—but for the system that let him get that far unchecked.

And maybe that’s the real story here. Not just about a guy getting what he deserved—but about one person, speaking up, refusing to let things stay broken.

It’s easy to complain about bad leadership. Harder to challenge it.

But if you do it right—with facts, with receipts, with patience—you might just fix more than you thought possible.

We didn’t just get our bonuses back.

We got our workplace back.

And we learned something big: You can’t fake integrity. Not forever.

So if you’re stuck under someone like Dick… keep your notes. Keep your head up. And when the moment comes?

Don’t be afraid to bring the truth to light.

If this story hit home for you, give it a like or share it. You never know who might need to hear it today.