Am I wrong for letting a complete stranger fight my son’s battle when I should have handled it myself?
My boy Tyler is nine. He has a speech impediment – a bad stutter that started when he was four and hasn’t let up no matter how much therapy we do. I’ve spent the last five years watching other kids destroy his confidence one interaction at a time, and I’ve spent those same five years biting my tongue and “taking the high road” because that’s what everyone tells you to do.
Saturday we went to the Boone County Fair. Tyler had been talking about it for weeks. He saved up eleven dollars of his own money for ride tickets and a funnel cake.
We were standing in line for the Scrambler when three boys – maybe eleven, twelve years old – got in line behind us. Within thirty seconds they were mimicking Tyler’s stutter. Not even behind his back. Right to his face.
“H-h-h-hey can I g-g-get a t-t-ticket,” one of them said, and the other two fell over each other laughing.
Tyler’s whole body went stiff. He grabbed the hem of my shirt and just held on.
I turned around. I told them to knock it off. The biggest one – this kid had to be pushing five foot five – looked me dead in the face and said, “We’re not talking to you, lady.”
I looked around for a parent, a fair worker, anyone. Nobody.
Then this guy behind them spoke up.
He was big. Full beard, leather vest, patches up and down his arms. Looked like he rode in with one of those motorcycle clubs that camps at the fairgrounds every year. He had a little girl on his shoulders eating cotton candy.
He set his daughter down. Walked up to the three boys. Didn’t touch them. Didn’t raise his voice. He got down on one knee so he was at their eye level and said, “You think that’s funny?”
The big kid crossed his arms. “Yeah. It IS funny.”
This man stood back up to his full height – he had to be six three, six four – and said, “Where’s your parents.”
Not a question. A command.
The kid’s face changed. All three of their faces changed. The smallest one pointed toward the food vendors.
He said, “Walk.”
They walked. He walked right behind them. I grabbed Tyler’s hand and followed because I didn’t know what else to do.
He marched those boys straight to a picnic table where a man and woman were sitting with plates of barbecue. The dad looked up and immediately got defensive. “What the hell is this?”
The biker looked at the dad and said, “Your boys just spent three minutes mocking a nine-year-old’s speech impediment to his face while his mother stood right there. You want to handle this, or do you want me to keep going?”
The dad stood up. Got in the biker’s face. Said, “You don’t tell me how to raise my kids, you piece of shit.”
And here’s where I maybe screwed up.
I should have pulled Tyler away. I should have de-escalated. I should have been the calm, reasonable mother everyone expects me to be.
Instead I stepped forward and told the dad EXACTLY what his sons said to my boy, word for word, while Tyler stood behind me shaking.
The mom started recording on her phone. The dad’s face was red. A crowd was forming. The biker hadn’t moved an inch.
Then the dad looked at Tyler – at my NINE-YEAR-OLD – and said, “Maybe if you could talk right, kids wouldn’t – “
The biker put his hand on the man’s chest. One hand. Flat. And he said something I couldn’t hear because my ears were ringing.
My friends are split. Half of them say I should have just reported it to fair security and walked away. My own mother told me I “put Tyler in a worse situation by making a scene.” My sister said I used a stranger as a weapon.
But Tyler hasn’t stopped talking about the man who stood up for him.
The fair posted the mom’s video to their Facebook page Monday morning with a statement. I hadn’t seen it yet. My phone started blowing up. I opened the video and watched it from the angle I couldn’t see, and when I heard what the biker actually said to that dad –
What the Video Showed
The angle was better than I expected. The mom had been recording longer than I realized, maybe from the moment we all walked up to the picnic table.
You could see everything I’d missed. The biker standing there with his arms at his sides, not clenched, not crossed. Just still. Like a guy waiting for a bus. The dad puffing up, leaning in, doing that thing men do when they want to look dangerous without actually committing to anything.
And when the dad said what he said about Tyler – about how maybe if Tyler “could talk right” – you could see the biker’s jaw move. Just once. Then his hand came up and settled flat on the dad’s chest. Not a shove. Just a stop.
And he said, loud enough that the phone picked it up clean: “My daughter is seven. She has a stutter too. You want to finish that sentence, go ahead. But you’re going to finish it in front of all these people, and you’re going to live with that.”
That was it.
The dad’s mouth opened. Closed.
The biker stepped back, picked his little girl up off the ground where she’d been standing this whole time holding her cotton candy with both hands, watching. He looked at Tyler. He said, “Good meeting you, buddy.” And he walked away.
I stood there with my kid while that family sat in total silence and a crowd of maybe forty strangers stared at them.
I didn’t feel victorious. I felt like I’d been hit by something.
The Ride Home
Tyler was quiet in the car for about ten minutes. I kept checking him in the rearview. He had a little sunburn starting across his nose. He still had funnel cake powder on his shirt.
Then he said, “Mom. Did you see his patches?”
I told him I’d noticed them, yeah.
“He had one that said Boone County Riders. I looked it up on my iPad and they do charity rides for kids with disabilities.”
I didn’t say anything.
“He had a daughter with a stutter,” Tyler said. “Like me.”
“I know, buddy.”
He looked out the window. “Do you think she gets made fun of too?”
I told him probably sometimes, yeah. And I waited for the question I knew was coming, the one every parent of a kid like Tyler dreads because there’s no good answer to it.
But he didn’t ask why. He just nodded, like that information had gone somewhere useful inside him, and he asked if we could stop for ice cream.
We stopped for ice cream.
What My Mother Got Wrong
She called Sunday morning. She’d heard about it from my aunt, who’d heard from my cousin, who apparently follows the Boone County Fair’s Facebook page for reasons I cannot explain.
She said I should have walked away. She said making a scene never helps. She said Tyler didn’t need to see his mother “lose control” in public.
I love my mother. She raised me mostly alone after my dad left when I was eleven, and she did it without complaining and without asking anyone for anything. She is tougher than anyone I know.
But she’s also the woman who once told me to just ignore a group of girls who’d been making my life miserable for an entire school year. And I did. And they didn’t stop. They just got bored and moved on to someone else, and I spent the rest of seventh grade convinced that the only acceptable response to cruelty was silence.
I’m not doing that to my kid.
I didn’t lose control at the fair. I was shaking, yeah. My voice cracked once when I was repeating back what those boys had said. But I stood there and I said it and I didn’t look away.
And Tyler was behind me, watching.
That part matters. I don’t care what anyone says about that part.
What My Sister Got Wrong
The “you used a stranger as a weapon” thing has stuck with me more than I expected, mostly because I’ve been trying to figure out if it’s true.
Here’s what I keep coming back to: I didn’t ask that man to do anything. I didn’t look at him helplessly. I didn’t recruit him. He made his own choice, the same way I made mine when I followed him to that picnic table.
He saw something happening and he decided it wasn’t going to keep happening. That’s not a weapon. That’s a person.
My sister means well. She’s conflict-averse in a way that I think she sometimes mistakes for wisdom. She’s the kind of person who leaves one-star reviews instead of talking to the manager, which sounds brave but is actually the opposite.
She also doesn’t have kids. Which isn’t a disqualifier. But it means she’s never stood in a line somewhere with a small person holding onto the hem of her shirt, shaking, while strangers performed cruelty at them like it was entertainment.
You make different calculations when someone’s holding onto you.
What Tyler Said Monday Night
The video had been up most of the day. I’d read the fair’s statement, which was careful and said a lot of words that added up to nothing. The comments were the usual mix. Half the people calling the biker a hero, half calling me a bad mother for not removing Tyler from the situation faster, a few people defending the other dad in ways that made me put my phone face-down on the counter and leave it there for an hour.
At bedtime Tyler asked me if people were being mean about it online.
I told him some were. I told him that’s pretty normal for anything that gets posted.
He said, “Are they being mean about me?”
I said some of them were saying I should have handled it differently.
He thought about this. He’s nine, but he thinks like someone who’s had to think carefully about things from a young age. Stuttering does that. When every sentence costs you something, you get selective about what’s worth saying.
He said, “You did handle it. You were there.”
Then he asked me to turn the light off.
The Thing I Can’t Stop Thinking About
The biker’s daughter.
She stood there the whole time holding that cotton candy. Seven years old, watching her dad walk up to three boys twice her size and kneel down and speak quietly to them. Watching him walk those boys to their parents. Watching the whole thing unfold.
She saw her dad do that.
And maybe she has a stutter. Maybe some days she comes home from school with that look Tyler gets, the one where his face is very still and his eyes are somewhere else. Maybe her dad has spent years watching other kids take her apart one comment at a time.
And maybe he decided, somewhere along the way, that the high road wasn’t the only road.
I don’t know his name. The fair’s statement didn’t name him. The comments were full of people saying they knew who he was, but nobody posted contact information and I didn’t go looking for it because I wasn’t sure what I’d say.
Thank you feels small. But it’s what I’ve got.
Tyler saved eleven dollars for that fair. He rode the Scrambler twice. He ate an entire funnel cake and got powdered sugar on both knees somehow. He talked to a stranger’s little girl in line for the Ferris wheel and I watched them standing there together, this small boy with a stutter and this small girl with a stutter, and they seemed to be getting along just fine.
He went to bed that night and he wasn’t broken.
That’s the whole answer to my own question. That’s it.
—
If this one got to you, pass it on. Someone else out there needs to read it.
For another story about a child facing a difficult situation, read about my seven-year-old foster son who had to face his abuser in court. You might also appreciate the story of the biker who handed me a card and told me to “read the back”, or the heartwarming tale of how forty bikers showed up for my seven-year-old at the courthouse.
