Am I wrong for letting a group of bikers walk my seven-year-old into court after the judge specifically told me to keep things “low-key”?
My daughter Molly has to testify next week. She’s seven. I can’t say much about the case but I can say this – the person she’s testifying against is someone she used to trust, and every night since the subpoena came she’s been sleeping on my bathroom floor because it’s the only room in the house with a lock.
I’ve been doing this alone. My ex, Darren (34M), signed away custody two years ago and moved to Reno. My mom helps when she can but she works nights at the hospital. It’s me and Molly. That’s it.
Three weeks ago Molly told her therapist she’d rather die than walk into that building. She’s SEVEN. Her therapist recommended I reach out to this organization – volunteers, most of them ride motorcycles – that escorts kids to court. They stand with the child so the child doesn’t feel alone. They’ve done this hundreds of times.
I called them. A woman named Denise called me back within an hour. She explained everything. They wear their vests, they ride to the courthouse, they walk the child in, and they sit in the hallway so the kid knows they’re there. That’s it. No drama. No confrontation.
I told my attorney, Patricia Koval. She said it was fine, she’d seen them before, totally legitimate.
Then the judge’s clerk called. Apparently the defense filed some kind of objection saying it was “intimidation tactics” and the judge told my attorney to advise me to keep things “low-key and appropriate for the setting.” Patricia said it wasn’t a formal order, just a strong suggestion.
I called Denise and told her. She said they’d be respectful, they always are, and it was my call.
I chose Molly.
Yesterday was the pre-testimony hearing. Molly and I pulled into the courthouse parking lot and eleven bikers were already there, standing in a line by their bikes. Molly saw them through the window and for the first time in three weeks she SMILED. Denise walked over, knelt down, and handed Molly a pin for her jacket.
We walked toward the entrance. Molly was holding Denise’s hand on one side and mine on the other. The whole group walked behind us. Quiet. Respectful. Nobody said a word.
Then the courthouse doors opened and the defense attorney was standing right there on the steps. He looked at the bikers, looked at me, pulled out his phone, and started recording.
He pointed at me and said, “This is exactly what I warned the court about. This is witness coaching. This is intimidation. I’m filing a motion to have her testimony thrown out ENTIRELY.”
Molly’s hand squeezed mine so hard her nails broke skin.
Denise stepped forward. She didn’t raise her voice. She said, “Sir, we’re here for the child. That’s all.”
He didn’t even look at her. He looked straight at me and said, “You just cost your daughter her case.”
My friends and family are split. My mom says I should have listened to the judge. Patricia says she can handle the motion but she’s not happy. My sister says I did the right thing. Denise hasn’t called me back yet.
Then this morning I got a voicemail from the clerk’s office. The judge wants to see me in chambers tomorrow. Alone. Without my attorney. And the message ended with –
What the Voicemail Actually Said
The message cut off. Not like there was more and it got clipped. It just ended mid-sentence, the clerk’s voice stopping right after “and the judge would like to speak with you regarding” and then nothing. Dead air. Then the automated “end of message” prompt.
I’ve listened to it nine times.
Patricia called me back twenty minutes after I called her in a panic. She said it was almost certainly a technical issue, a dropped recording, nothing sinister. She also said she’d never heard of a judge requesting a party appear in chambers without counsel present. That the clerk must have misspoken or the message was incomplete.
She said she’d call the clerk’s office first thing in the morning and get clarification.
She said not to worry.
I didn’t sleep.
Molly slept on the bathroom floor again. I sat outside the door on the hallway carpet with my back against the wall and my phone in my hand and I watched the voicemail timestamp until it was 4 a.m.
What Nobody Tells You About Being the Only One
Darren texts maybe once a month. Usually something like “hows she doing” without a question mark, and I write back “fine” and that’s the whole conversation. He doesn’t know about the case. I made that call six months ago and I’d make it again. He’d either disappear completely or he’d show up and make it about him, and I don’t have the bandwidth for either.
My mom. She’s good. She’s solid. But she’s sixty-one and she’s working three twelve-hour shifts a week at the hospital because her retirement got gutted in 2009 and she never fully recovered from it. She comes over on her days off and she brings Molly those orange crackers with the peanut butter inside, the ones in the little pack, because Molly’s been eating like a bird for three weeks and those are the only thing she’ll reliably finish.
We don’t talk about how bad it is. We just sit together.
My sister, Renee, lives forty minutes away in a house with four kids and a husband who travels. She calls. She’s good at calling. She said I did the right thing, and I believe she believes that, but she also hasn’t seen what Molly looks like at two in the morning when she wakes up and can’t remember where she is.
So it’s me. It has been me. And when Denise’s group showed up in that parking lot, eleven people who didn’t know us at all, who drove forty-five minutes on a Tuesday morning because a therapist filled out a referral form, I stood next to my car and I had to breathe through my nose for a second because I almost fell apart right there in the parking lot.
Molly didn’t notice. She was already walking toward them.
The Pin
It’s small. Enamel. A little motorcycle on it, red, with tiny white wheels. Denise pressed it into Molly’s palm and said, “That means you’ve got a whole crew now.”
Molly looked at it for a long time.
Then she looked up at this woman she’d never met, this big woman in a leather vest with patches on it, gray hair in a braid, reading glasses pushed up on her head, and Molly said, “Are you going to be there when I have to talk?”
Denise said, “We’ll be right outside the door.”
Molly put the pin on her jacket collar herself, without help, and she stood up straight.
I watched a seven-year-old decide to be brave in real time. Right there in a parking lot outside a courthouse. And I am not going to apologize for the people who made that possible.
What the Defense Attorney Doesn’t Understand
His name is Glenn Harbert. I know this because Patricia has mentioned him a dozen times in the last four months, usually in the same tone you’d use for a slow leak in a tire. Persistent. Annoying. Manageable.
He’s good at his job. That’s the thing. He’s not a cartoon. He’s a real attorney doing what defense attorneys do, which is find every available angle, apply pressure to every weak point, and see what breaks.
He looked at eleven bikers in leather vests walking a child into a courthouse and he saw an angle.
What he filmed: a group of adults accompanying a minor to a legal proceeding.
What he told the court it was: a coordinated intimidation campaign designed to prejudice the jury pool and coach the witness.
What it actually was: a little girl who’d been sleeping on a bathroom floor for three weeks finally standing up straight.
He doesn’t have to care about the difference. That’s not his job.
But I keep thinking about the way he looked at me when he said “you just cost your daughter her case.” Not at Molly. Not at the bikers. At me. Like I was the problem to be solved. Like I was the one who had done something wrong to everyone involved.
Molly’s nails left four small marks on the inside of my hand. I’ve been looking at them all day.
Patricia’s Version of Events
She called at 7:30 this morning. The clerk’s office confirmed the meeting is real. It’s not ex parte, which is the legal term for a private communication between a judge and one party that the other party doesn’t know about and which is, in most circumstances, not allowed. Patricia said the judge has invited both attorneys. It’s a conference. The clerk just worded the voicemail badly.
So I’m not walking in there alone.
I exhaled so hard I had to sit down.
Patricia also said the motion Harbert filed is thin. That organizations like Denise’s group have appeared in cases in this state before. That there’s no precedent for excluding a child’s testimony because the child had emotional support walking into the building. That if anything, Harbert’s aggressive response on the courthouse steps, on camera, pointing at a seven-year-old’s mother while the child was standing right there, might have created more problems for him than for us.
She said “might.” She’s careful with her words.
She also said, and I’m writing this down because I want to remember it exactly: “You didn’t violate an order. You made a parenting decision. Those are different things.”
Tomorrow
Molly’s at school. She goes every day, which I think is brave in a way she doesn’t know yet. She carries the pin in her jacket pocket now instead of wearing it because a kid in her class asked about it and she didn’t want to explain.
I packed her lunch this morning. Peanut butter, no jelly, because she’s been on a no-jelly thing for two months. Apple slices. Those orange crackers, the ones with the peanut butter inside, because my mom bought three boxes and left them on my counter.
I wrote a note on her napkin. I do this every day. Today it said: You are so brave. I’ll be here when you get off the bus.
I folded it twice and put it under the crackers.
Then I sat at the kitchen table for a while. The house was quiet. My coffee went cold.
I keep thinking about what Harbert said. About how I cost Molly her case. And I think about the parking lot, and the pin, and the way she stood up straight.
I don’t know what the judge is going to say tomorrow. I don’t know if Patricia’s right that the motion is thin, or if Harbert found an angle that actually works. I don’t know if I made the right tactical call.
But Molly smiled. For the first time in three weeks, she smiled.
She walked through those doors holding Denise’s hand and mine, and she didn’t look back, and she didn’t freeze, and she didn’t ask to leave.
She walked in.
I’ll find out tomorrow what that cost us. But I already know what it was worth.
—
If this one got to you, share it. Someone out there needs to know they’re not the only one making impossible calls alone.
For more tales of unexpected courtroom twists, check out The Man Who’d Been Leaving Me Hundred-Dollar Tips Walked Into My Courtroom Hearing in a Suit, or if you’re in the mood for some justified outrage, read about My Little Brother Has a Stutter and a Bruise, and I Lost It in the School Parking Lot.
